Two Timely Issues: The New Mass and the Possibility of a Heretical Pope

No tax

Author: Dr Arnaldo Xavier da Silveira, [1929-2018]

Translators: John Spann & Jose Schelini

Publisher: The Foundation for a Christian Civilization, Inc

Year of English publication: 2022 [1970 1st Portuguese ed]

Pages 365

Binding: hardback


Pope Paul VI’s action in September 1973 to prevent the publication of this book, as explained by José Antonio Ureta in the foreword to the present edition, prompted Bishop Antonio de Castro Mayer of Campos, Brazil to write to the Holy Father on January 25, 1974.  Bishop Mayer in his letter referred to his previous October 15 communication with the Pope, in which he manifested his “filial compliance” with Paul VI’s request.  In this second letter, he cited the Holy Father’s permission for him to “freely express to the Holy See” his opinions, if in conscience he did not agree with certain acts of Pope Paul’s Magisterium.

The promulgation of the new rite of the Mass, the novus ordo missae, intending to replace the traditional Latin rite, was one such act that deeply concerned Bishop Antonio de Castro Mayer.  Therefore in his letter to the Pope he expressed his agreement with the contents of this book by Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira.  And he did so after appealing to the Holy Father for an understanding of his concerns.  “I implore Your Holiness to have compassion toward the obedience of this Bishop, now seventy years old, who is currently experiencing the most dramatic episode of his life. And I ask Your Holiness to grant me at least a portion of that understanding and that benevolence that you have so often manifested not only around you, but also with people who are strangers, and even enemies of the one fold of the one Shepherd.”  Six paragraphs above in his letter, he had manifested his intention regarding those opinions that he was expressing to the Pope: “It is not my intention to hand them over to the public, certain that my reserve will please Your Holiness.”

In the years immediately following these events, however, Paul VI did not respond favorably to the wishes of Bishop Mayer and those of all the faithful who wanted to preserve the traditional liturgy.  In May of 1976, at a consistory of Cardinals, Paul VI criticized Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre for adhering to the traditional rite, and stated that he wanted every priest to celebrate the new rite.  In 1984 his successor, Pope John Paul II, granted an indult, which was interpreted as an exception to the law, allowing the traditional Mass when permitted by the local bishop.  But later a commission of Cardinals, set up by the same Pope to study the canonical status of the traditional rite, concluded in their majority that Paul VI had not in fact abolished the traditional rite, which in effect made an indult unnecessary because the rite had not been abrogated.  Nevertheless, opposition to the traditional Mass continued, and in June of 1988 Archbishop Lefebvre, joined by Bishop Mayer, consecrated four bishops in order to assure that priests would continue to be ordained to celebrate the traditional rite.

For nineteen more years the controversy within the Church continued, until Benedict XVI officially declared in his motu proprio Summorum Pontificum of July 7, 2007 that the traditional rite was never abrogated.  However, that declaration was challenged by the July 2021 motu proprio Traditionis Custodes of Pope Francis.

In view of this history of nearly five decades, manifested at first by Bishop Mayer’s reserve in not going public to express his deep concerns, has given way, in the face of a worldwide effort to suppress the traditional rite, to the need to explain to Catholics throughout the world the reasons behind the public resistance to its suppression.  The traditional rite must be preserved – as many Catholics firmly believe – because the new rite does not fully express the sacrifice of propiation that is realized in the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass.  Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira demonstrates that there is no other possible explanation of the theology behind the new rite. For the explanations given, by those who were its most representative advocates, demonstrate a radically new understanding of the Mass, different from what the Church has always taught throughout the centuries.


Data sheet

Year Published & Pages
2022 [1970 1st Portuguese ed]
Dr Arnaldo Xavier da Silveira, [1929-2018]


Write your review

Two Timely Issues: The New Mass and the Possibility of a Heretical Pope

Author: Dr Arnaldo Xavier da Silveira, [1929-2018]

Translators: John Spann & Jose Schelini

Publisher: The Foundation for a Christian Civilization, Inc

Year of English publication: 2022 [1970 1st Portuguese ed]

Pages 365

Binding: hardback

Write your review

Ordering from Canada? Click HERE!

Recent News from PCP

Catalog 194 PDF download


May 3, 2023:

Bishop Mayer’s January 1974 Letter to Pope Paul VI 

April 6, 2020 & April 20, 2022:

The Solitary Mission of Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò

Part I: The Passion of the Church 

Part II: From Religious Commentary to Political Speculation

Part III:  The Theology of History

April 7, May 5 & Sep 8, 2022:

The Third Secret and the Consecration of Russia

Part I: The Facts

Part II: Two Opposed Catholic Reactions 

Part III: The Controversial Nature of Russia's Conversion

July 3, 2022:

Bishop Schneider on the Two Prophets of Our Time

August 11, 2020, January 20 & February 24, 2022:

Vatican II and 
Catholic Family News

Part I 

Part II

Part III

December 16, 2021:

"Eucharistic Coherence" and Communion in the Hand

November 24, 2021, November 8, 2021 & August 12, 2021 

The Young Father Ratzinger and the Two Motu Proprio

Part I - The Restoration of Divine Worship

Part II - The Restoration of Worship & the New Priestly Societies

Part III - St. Bonaventure & the "Passion" of the Church

August 18, 2021:

Francis - a Poem

July 23, 2021:

Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò & Prof. Roberto de Mattei – Part III

July 9, 2021:

Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò & Prof. Roberto de Mattei – Part II

June 30, 2021:

Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò & Prof. Roberto de Mattei – Part I

June 24, 2021:

Our Lady of Good Success, Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre and Plinio Correa de Oliveira-Part III

March 12, 2021:

Our Lady of Good Success, Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre and Plinio Correa de Oliveira–Part II

January 27, 2021:

Our Lady of Good Success, Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre and Plinio Correa de Oliveira-Part I

January 9, 2021:

The Remnant Reviews Bishop Laise's Book

October 9, 2020:

Italian Theologian on Bishop Laise and
Communion on the Tongue

Communion in the Hand: disobedience permitted

Bishop's Laise Letter on Communion in the Hand

Comunion en la mano: una desobediencia

Carta de Mons. Laise acerca de la comunión en la mano

La communion dans la main: une désobéissance autorisée

In Memoriam S.E. Mgr Juan Rodolfo Laise au premier anniversaire de son décès

July 2, 2020:

Archbishop Viganò, and Bishop Schneider Discuss the Council

June 16, 2020:

Catholic Solidarity and American Civil Strife 

June 10, 2020:

Archbishop Viganò, Fatima and Civitavecchia

June 4, 2020:

Episcopal Leaders in the Face of the World Crisis

May 29, 2020:

Liturgical Law in the Midst of the Pandemic

May 19, 2020:

Coronavirus, Subsidiarity and Catholic Doctrine

May 13, 2020:

The Message from Fatima and St. Robert Bellarmine

May 9, 2020:

From Communion in the Hand to No Communion

May 1, 2020:

The Third Secret, Bishop Schneider, and Archbishop Vigano

April 25, 2020:

Fundamental Catholic Principles in the Midst of a Global Crisis

April 15, 2020:

Corona Virus and the Leadership Role of Catholic Countries

April 6, 2020:

The Passion of the Church: The Solitary Mission of Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò

March 26, 2020:

Communion on the Tongue and the Coronavirus

February 21, 2020:

Statements from the Hierarchy on the Crisis in the Church

October 21, 2019:

The Fundamental Assumption of the Amazon Synod

October 3, 2019:

Bishop Antonio de Castro Mayer’s
Defense of Plinio Corrêa de Oliveira

July 25, 2019:

Bishop Juan Rodolfo Laise, OFMCap.,
Defender of the Holy Eucharist, R.I.P

June 22, 2019:

Bishop de Castro Mayer & Plinio Corrêa de Oliveira

April 25, 2019:

Plinio Corrêa de Oliveira: Prophet of the
Reign of Mary by Roberto de Mattei

New Product!

1962 Parish Ritual


January 5, 2019:

Bishop Laise: How Catholics Must Receive Communion Worthily


November 24, 2018:

SSPX Transforms Third Secret Debate


October 15, 2018:

The Saint Michael Prayer and the Pope


September 27, 2018:

Pope Leo XIII and the Prayer to St. Michael: Second Enlarged Edition


May 17, 2018:

Rome, Jerusalem and Washington


January 23, 2018:

Third Secret Update


November 18, 2017:

The Kevin Symonds-Christopher Ferrara Debate on the Third Secret


September 18, 2017:

The Church & Health Care: An Appeal to Silent Bishops


July 15, 2017:

The Common Good, Mr. Ferrara and the Pope


June 16, 2017:

The Vine and the Branches


May 31, 2017:

Fatima, the Role of Catholic Professionals


Fatima and the Third Secret

After the publication of the Third Secret of Fatima on June 26, 2000, speculation began almost immediately among many who thought the Vatican had not published the entire text of the Secret. Read more...


Newsletter June 15, 2016:

Our Lady of Fatima and Russia – Catalog 177

Newsletter April 5, 2016:

The History of the Saint Michael Book

Newsletter December 18, 2015:

A new Catholic Bibliographical Index has been launched!


Pope Leo XIII and the Prayer to St. Michael – Catalog 174

Mention is often made of Leo XIII and a famous vision that he saw – that of an attack being made or planned by the devil against the Church. The facts about this vision, however, have been unclear for many decades, for there are different versions of what occurred, and of what was or was not said in that vision. What is fact and what is fiction about this event in modern papal history? Read more...


Newsletter July 28, 2015:

Cardinal Merry del Val on the Authority of the Pope – Catalog 173

Newsletter May 27, 2015:

Bishop Juan Rodolfo Laise: Rome Never Approved Communion in the Hand – Catalog 172

Newsletter April 27, 2015:

Fatima, the Errors of Russia, and Two Catholic Classics

Newsletter April 14, 2015:

Cardinal Ruffini and the Days of Creation – A Challenge from Hugh Owen

Newsletter April 8, 2015:

Bella Dodd's School of Darkness – now back in print

Newsletter March 23, 2015:

An Evolution Debate in The Wanderer and Cardinal Ruffini's Book

Newsletter February 9, 2015:

Nigerian Bishop Calls for a Holy War / A Lenten Book on the Passion

Email Newsletter January 26, 2015:

Catalog 170, & Juan Donoso Cortés’s Prophecy of Today’s European Crisis

Email Newsletter January 19, 2015:

Preserving Christian Publications back online – with 5,000 Catholic Book Titles